For many, the main pro is that it’s vegan. Bakuchiol comes entirely from plants, while retinol (a form of vitamin A) is sometimes still sourced from animal products.
Vegan retinol does exist, though, so be sure to check the labels before you brush it off completely.
Also, bakuchiol’s typically considered a gentler approach. Though retinol has plenty of success stories, it’s not exactly low-maintenance – it's not always suitable for delicate skin and should only be applied at night because of its heated relationship with the sun.
Bakuchiol’s said to have similar effects – smoothing skin, increasing glow and helping to blur fine lines – without the hassle. Oh, and there’s no
“retinol uglies”...
A small study published in the British Journal of Dermatology in 2019 showed very similar results between retinol and bakuchiol creams.2 Bakuchiol users had a slightly higher reduction in hyperpigmentation and less burning sensation than retinol, though they reported slightly more redness. It’s worth noting here that the study was small and more research is needed – but it could be promising news for bakuchiol fans.
Another study, featuring 60 women aged 40-65, showed that bakuchiol was tolerated well and showed improvements in visual smoothness and radiance.3 While cheek corneometry measurements showed a 16% increase in skin moisture content.3